[ ]   [ ]   [ ]                        [ ]      [ ]   [ ]
Neil Young — Carmichael
Album: Greendale
Avg rating:
4.7

Your rating:
Total ratings: 77









Released: 2003
Length: 10:03
Plays (last 30 days): 0
share tweet wikiwebsitesearchamg
cd
mp3
search
(no lyrics available)
Comments (12)add comment
Eul0gy wrote:
the less neil young, the better, his songs are fine when sung by someone else who actually has talent.
Except even this one probably couldn't be saved by someone else singing it. Jesus, it's making me tense!
Posted 20 years ago by qbee    [ Reply ]
the less neil young, the better, his songs are fine when sung by someone else who actually has talent.
Posted 20 years ago by Eul0gy    [ Reply ]
This album is fantastic! Follow the story, follow the music, or follow both. The soul is there, baby. This is a glorious Neil "ditch" album. Rock on, Mr Young, you are one of the last of the true originals!
Posted 20 years ago by mnuisance    [ Reply ]
In order for me to tolerate Neil Young, he needs to be singing an exceptional song - and he does have a few. This one is not. :P
Posted 20 years ago by reviep    [ Reply ]
Perhaps he could have practiced the guitar a bit more before recording? The usual Neil Young fecal matter.
Posted 20 years ago by Roverfish    [ Reply ]
Very fine....like the first two albums of decades ago. Play more!
Posted 20 years ago by Bard    [ Reply ]
Thanks Bill - Saved me $15!
Posted 20 years ago by Spliff    [ Reply ]
very nice - neil writes the best lyrics and is such a talented musician - I really enjoy listening to him - great addition to the playlist RP
Posted 20 years ago by BQHsMom    [ Reply ]
I know this is supposed to be a concept album and haven't heard the rest of the album; but, it sounds like Neil wrote some lyrics and made no real specific attempt to create the music around the words (Ok, let's play this one in G guys). If he had something to say, he could have tried a little harder to make the music convey the message as well.
Posted 20 years ago by black321    [ Reply ]
Like, um, almost every song he ever did? I dunno, I still like him, even if this sounds like a glorified three-chord garage band.
Posted 20 years ago by rgrace    [ Reply ]
This is interminable.
Posted 20 years ago by ndanger666    [ Reply ]
Not one of Neil\'s best.
Posted 20 years ago by leathepea    [ Reply ]